Israel and Ireland (Flags) (Representative Image)
Photo : iStock
Israel announced the closure of its embassy in Dublin following Ireland’s decision to back a petition at the International Court of Justice (ICJ) accusing Israel of genocide. The action was a reaction to Ireland’s “extreme anti-Israeli policies,” according to Israeli Foreign Minister Gideon Sa’ar.
Given that Ireland has been one of the most outspoken European states in favor of Palestinian rights, the decision signaled a major increase in tensions between the two countries. One important aspect, according to Sa’ar, was Ireland’s backing of South Africa’s ICJ appeal under the Genocide Convention, which he saw as a component of “antisemitic actions” against Israel. He charged Dublin of smearing the Jewish state and using unfair treatment.
The Irish government justified its position by claiming that it was based on upholding international law and human rights. Simon Harris, the Irish Taoiseach, denied any anti-Israel feeling while calling Israel’s decision to close the embassy “deeply regrettable.” Harris reaffirmed Ireland’s commitment to regional peace and support for a two-state solution.
Longstanding Strains in Bilateral Relations
Ireland’s pro-Palestinian position has long caused tensions in relations between Israel and Ireland. Ireland’s unilateral acceptance of a Palestinian state has already prompted Israel to remove its ambassador from Dublin. These tense interactions are still present in the most recent events.
Shortly after Irish Tánaiste Micheál Martin stated that Ireland’s government has authorized legal participation in South Africa’s ICJ case, Israel made its declaration. The lawsuit seeks to expand international law’s definition of genocide. Martin maintained that Israel’s military operations in Gaza, which resulted in millions of people being displaced and tens of thousands of deaths, amounted to collective punishment.
Sa’ar outlined intentions to refocus Israel’s diplomatic efforts on countries with better relations. Declaring Moldova to be a nation seeking closer connections with Israel, he announced plans to build a new embassy there.
Wider Implications Amid Gaza Conflict
Ireland’s special situation was further highlighted by Israel’s decision to refrain from taking comparable diplomatic action against other countries who supported the ICJ case, such as Spain, Mexico, and Egypt. According to critics, the action would widen already-existing rifts over Middle East policy in Europe.
Reports of increasing violence in Gaza were made at the same time as the announcement. Health officials in the region said that more than 45,000 people had died in the fighting as of Sunday. At least 15 people were killed by Israeli airstrikes that struck many locations over the weekend, including a school in Beit Hanoun. 17 people, including women and children, were killed in attacks on private dwellings in Gaza City.
The violence did not spare journalists. An attack on a civil emergency facility in Nuseirat killed Ahmed Al-Louh, a video journalist for Al Jazeera. The incident claimed the lives of five more people.
Legal and Diplomatic Fallout
The diplomatic split occurred as Israel faced further legal difficulties. In November, the ICC issued arrest warrants for former Defense Minister Yoav Gallant and Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu. Alleged war crimes, such as famine and crimes against humanity, were included in the warrants. Since then, Israel has appealed the warrants.
Ireland’s legal stance, according to observers, was part of a larger movement to reinterpret governmental responsibility for genocide. Martin emphasized the need for further protections for civilians and said that limited definitions of genocide lead to impunity.
